'Overage' is a form of clawback; it gives the seller a right to
get extra money from the buyer on the happening of some future event (eg the
grant of planning permission).
It is, as we have frequently noted in the past,
something that can cause enormous problems in drafting. This checklist highlights
obvious points to consider:
- duration: how long is the overage agreement to last for?
- planning application: insist on specifying the extent of the involvement
of each party in the planning application; should there be specific time limits
(or an obligation to use best endeavours); should there be provisions for
progress reports and copy documents; consider an obligation to maximise the
value of the land (and to apply for the most valuable permission); and should
there be an obligation to appeal (perhaps subject to the view of counsel on
merits)?
- planning permission: this may well be defined as a trigger event.
But, are you referring to outline or detailed permission? What about onerous
conditions, and what if the permission is obtained by a third party (not the
contracting parties)?
- trigger events: apart from planning, what other events might trigger
payment? For instance, this might be on disposal (in which case define precisely
what that means – and assure there are provisions for any sale to be
arms length, and not a collusive sale);
- the overage amount: it may be a fixed sum (should it be index-linked?),
or perhaps a share of profits (consider an obligation to keep accounts, and
consider what happens if there will be more than single payment). If there
are references to ‘market value’ then consider provisions dealing
with special purchasers (eg collusion), vacant possession, encumbrances, costs
of complying with planning obligations, and whether there should be disregard
in respect of other rights or land held that affect the planning position;
- less favourable development: should there be a clause to deal
with the situation when there are unexpected problems (eg changes in legislation),
with a reduced overage payment in those situations?
This is merely a taster of the problems that can arise. There are other issues
to be considered such as interest for late payment, drafting of positive covenants
(eg gifts, deaths, leases and charges to be dealt with), and what restrictions
should be on the title; what releases should be given, and should the unpaid
vendor’s lien be excluded?).
As we have said before, overage is a complex topic and is not for the inexperienced.
If in doubt, take specialist advice.
|
|
April 2005 |